Cake vs. Ice Cream: How to Choose the Perfect Wedding Day Dessert

There’s something so nostalgic about choosing your wedding day dessert, but here’s the thing, it doesn’t have to be traditional to be memorable. Cake has been the go-to forever, but more and more couples are realizing that, honestly… not everyone even likes cake anymore! I’m known for my cake tastings (and trust me, I love them!), but I’ve seen firsthand how couples light up when they choose a dessert that actually feels like them. Whether it’s cake, ice cream, or something totally different, your wedding dessert should make you excited, not obligated!

Wedding Day Dessert: Why Cake Isn’t Always the Winner

Let’s be real for a second: a lot of couples spend hundreds on a big, beautiful cake that ends up barely touched. Outside of the cake cutting moment, most people don’t eat more than a few bites, or none at all! That doesn’t mean cake is “wrong,” but it does mean you don’t have to feel boxed into tradition if cake isn’t your thing. Maybe you’re not a frosting person, maybe you only like certain flavors, or maybe the whole idea just feels a little too expected. Choosing a Wedding Day Dessert you’ll actually crave makes the moment so much more intentional. Plus, you’ll look back on that choice and remember how fun and true-to-you it felt.

Wedding Day Dessert Ideas: Why Ice Cream Deserves Its Moment

Now, let’s talk ice cream, because this is where people’s eyes really light up. Ice cream on your wedding day? It’s unexpected, it’s playful, and it’s genuinely loved by almost everyone. It turns dessert into a cute little “experience” rather than just another plated slice. You can offer different flavors, toppings, cones, mini cups, the whole thing feels customizable and fun. And the best part? You’re not forcing yourself or your guests to eat something just because it’s tradition. Choosing an ice cream cart, gelato bar, or even your favorite local scoop shop creates a moment that feels fresh, joyful, and totally you!

Ready to Make Your Wedding Dessert Actually Fun? Let’s Chat!

KJB Studios | Atlanta & Destination Wedding Photographer & Videographer

If you’re dreaming up a wedding day that feels intentional, joyful, and a little outside the box, choosing a dessert you truly love is such an easy place to start. Cake, ice cream, or something completely different, it should taste like you. And if you want help dreaming up ideas, planning something fun, or capturing every sweet moment along the way, I’m always here to chat through it. Head to my contact page so we can chat about the ideas you have! If you want to learn more about me and what I do, click here. Can’t wait to hear from you!